How did Sherlock survive the fall? Part 2
January 4, 2014
Posted by on
My attempt on 20 January 2012 to cover all the possibilities has been vindicated. The answer, according to the numbering of my earlier list, is: “Option 5”, but with an inflatable rather than cardboard boxes. My hunch that Molly was part of the plan was also correct. Many people correctly surmised the use of a ball under Sherlock’s armpit to stop the pulse in his arm while Watson attempted to take it.
Once again, I notice Mark Gatiss’s penchant for making puns out of the titles of the original stories (‘The Empty Hearse’ instead of Empty House) and his wanton propensity for using plots from the originals as mere ornaments, rather than episodes in their own right. This happened in S3E1 with ‘A Case of Identity’ (the tearful woman, accompanied by an older man with whom she was lodging, bemoaning the fact that her on-line companion had apparently disappeared).
The reason why Sherlock’s name appears so frequently in this blog is that, while fictional, he is outstandingly the most famous fellow sufferer of hyperlexia. (I wonder if Mark Gatiss was playing Mycroft or speaking for himself when he utters line, “I live in a world of goldfish.”) My attacks always get worse immediately before, during, and for a while after each programme. I deplore the harmful and insensitive ways the word clouds are used. The fact that they are on screen for too short a time even for some-one like me to assimilate them is one thing, and that can be offset by using the pause button. However, the content of these word clouds is infuriating. Take the scene in S3E1 when Sherlock, Watson and Mary are standing outside the restaurant, after Watson has tried to sublimate the shock of seeing Sherlock again by attacking him. The word cloud which appears contains some terms which make it obvious how they arose: ‘cat lover’, for example. However, another one was ‘Lib Dem’, which is infuriating. Unless it was something as obvious as the bit of metal on Jabez Wilson’s watch-chain in ‘The Red-headed League’ which indicated that he was a freemason, I do not see how you can tell that some-one supports the Liberal Democrats merely by looking at him or her. If the writers have a practical hypothesis of how all the terms in the word cloud arose, they should show it. If they do not, then they are not only belittling their own artistic creation, but they are scoundrels.